Nothing is as it seems in 'Heretic': Dark, thought-provoking thriller delivers
"Heretic" isn't just another horror film. It's a layered psychological thriller, diving into the power dynamics of belief and the influence of organized religion.
Directed by Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, the movie builds suspense through its foreshadowing and philosophical discourse, creating a tense atmosphere that leaves viewers questioning faith and autonomy.
With a story that examines religious manipulation through the lens of the "truth," "Heretic" offers a disturbing, yet thought-provoking experience.
The film opens with two young Mormon missionaries, Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East), when they arrive at the home of Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant). Grant's Reed first appears as a curious skeptic, but as the story unfolds, it becomes clear that he harbors more sinister intentions.
His deep knowledge of religious history and unsettling ability to challenge the missionaries' beliefs set the stage for a powerful exchange that keeps viewers on edge. While you should see "Heretic" for yourself, it'd be impossible to examine its scarier parts without spoiling them, so consider yourself warned.
One of the film's most haunting moments comes when Sister Barnes mentions that she hopes to be reincarnated as a butterfly when she dies. While seemingly small, this moment becomes significant in the movie's conclusion. When only Sister Paxton manages to escape from Reed's grasp, a butterfly lands on her hand — a subtle yet chilling reminder of her friend and everything they endured together.
Grant delivers a powerful performance as Mr. Reed, bringing an eerie intensity to his character. Reed manipulates the missionaries' beliefs with a disturbing calmness, as he asserts that "true" religion is about control. His character isn't merely questioning faith, he's weaponizing it.
Grant's portrayal makes Reed an unsettling antagonist, twisting ideas of faith and power with a kind of intellectual charisma that challenges both the missionaries and the audience.
What sets "Heretic" apart from typical horror flicks is its approach to tension. Directors Beck and Woods avoid the usual jump scares, favoring a slow-burn style that relies on intense dialogue and layered themes to build suspense.
This approach keeps viewers on edge in a way that feels intelligent and captivating. The horror in "Heretic" isn't just about fear, it's about the disturbing implications of Reed's arguments and the vulnerability of belief.
The film also explores complex questions about faith and control. By presenting religion as something that can be twisted into a tool for manipulation, "Heretic" delves into the darker aspects of trust and authority.
Reed's assertion that all religions are simply systems of control echoes historical critiques from figures like Karl Marx, yet the film never forces an agenda. Instead, it presents these ideas in a way that challenges the viewer to think deeply about the role of faith and the power structures that often shape it.
For fans of psychological thrillers, "Heretic" is a must-watch. It's a movie that doesn't rely on flashy effects or easy scares. Rather, it builds its horror through an exploration of ideas. By the time the credits roll, "Heretic" has left an impression that goes beyond typical horror, staying with you long after you leave the theater.
It's dark, smart and deeply unsettling, offering a unique take on horror that's as intellectual as it is chilling.